Nobody big except me is the dream world of holden caulfield and his first person story is down to the basic, drab english of the precollegiate. The writing was monotonous, and the premise of being written by an unborn baby was a cliche. What, for instance, are this neonatal hamlets bad dreams. He studied at the university of sussex, where he received a ba degree in english literature in 1970. Nutshell by ian mcewan told from a perspective unlike any other, nutshell is a classic tale of murder and deceit from one of the worlds master storytellers buy the book. However, in this adaptation, the role of hamlet is essentially played by an inutero child within trudys this versions gertrude womb. John boyne on a novel narrated by an eavesdropping foetus.
About this book oh god, i could be bounded in a nutshell and count myself king of infinite spacewere it not that i have bad dreams. Ian mcewan nutshell, safe spaces and identity politics. Our club has read books that tell stories from the point of view of a dog, a dead girl, a drunk, and a madman, so sure, i was game to read this book. This was my sixth novel by ian mcewan, and though id be hardpressed to say which has been my favourite so far, its safe to say nutshell now ranks among my favourite novels of all time. When did you realise that the novel was a retelling of hamlet. Ian mcewan is the bestselling author of seventeen books, including the novels nutshell.
Nutshell is the most amazing novel from the greatest of writersgloriously entertaining, wonderfully imagineda mesmerizing thriller to delight all readers. Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read. This guide was created using the following version of this text. A bravura performance, it is the finest recent work from a true master. Nutshell is an orb, a venetian glass paperweight, of a book. Jan 30, 2017 jan 30, 2017 nutshell discussion questions ian mcewan. Chosen as a book group read but, having missed the meeting at which it was chosen, i knew absolutely nothing about it other than i have loved most of the other ian mcewan books that i have read. I know that ian mcewan is a well regarded author, but this is the second book of his that i have read the children act was the other and it will be my last. Melissa cacace cardito yes, the pov is the unborn baby boy. Its written from the perspective of an unborn child who knows what his mother and lover are proposing to do. Oh god, i could be bounded in a nutshell and count myself a king of infinite spacewere it not that i have bad dreams. May 29, 2017 nutshell is an orb, a venetian glass paperweight, of a book. How is it that i, not even young, not even born yesterday, could know so much, or know enough to be wrong about so much. The idea behind ian mcewans new novel, nutshell an imagining of the events leading up to hamlet.
Jan 08, 2018 ive read many of mcewans books and all of them have been good, with atonement being my favorite. But ian mcewans virtuoso entertainment is almost certainly the first to combine the two. Solar, winner of the bollinger everyman wodehouse prize. Sep 23, 2016 nutshell by ian mcewan 208pp, jonathan cape. Feb 28, 2017 this feature is not available right now. Are there any good questions to present to my book club about nutshell.
Nutshell is a classic story of murder and deceit, told by a narrator with a perspective and. Sep 11, 2016 an unborn baby overhears plans for a murder in ian mcewans latest novel. Nutshell by ian mcewan is a modern retelling of william shakespeares. Sep 16, 2016 told from a perspective unlike any other, nutshell is a classic tale of murder and deceit from one of the worlds master storytellers. Ian mcewan discusses his new novel, nutshell youtube. A tawdry murder story and stopped working marriage offer the stress, a dimwitted uncle provides a foil and an extremely astute fetus supplies moving testimony and viewpoint. Sep 15, 2016 why ian mcewan doesnt see his latest novel as being science. It retells william shakespeare s play hamlet from the point of view of an unborn child, and is set in 2015. About this guide this guide is designed to enhance your groups discussion of nutshell, the brilliant new novel from ian mcewan.
A violent surfacing of adolescence which has little in common with tarkingtons earlier, broadly comic, seventeen has a compulsive impact. Nutshell is an orb, a venetian glass paperweight, of a. And what lies withinthe suspense of a murder plot, the matching game thats played when a classic story is retold, and the unique perspective of an unborn narratoris quite pleasurable to both pick through and savor. To ask other readers questions about nutshell, please sign up. Jan 30, 2017 nutshell discussion questions ian mcewan. Nutshell, his new novel, features a foetus listening in on a murder plot. Nutshell book club notes for a book club unlike any other. Nutshell by ian mcewan is a modern retelling of william shakespeares classic play hamlet. Nutshell discussion questions ian mcewan this or that. Nutshell is narrated by an eightandahalfmonthold baby boy from inside the womb. Ian mcewans nutshell is an unconventional reinterpretation of.
An unborn baby overhears plans for a murder in ian mcewan. Pretty impressive and one of five very good reasons for reading ian mcewan. Hamlet, act ii, scene 2 trudy has been unfaithful to her husband, john. It was a book club pick and many in the group agreed that it was humorous in its own way, but some felt it was a little overthetop with its pretentiousness. Do you think this statement is true in regards to nutshell. The prose is unbelievably beautiful and the babys insight ismore yes, the pov is the unborn baby boy. Im normally a fan of ian mcewan but this book fell short being too wordy and contrived. An unborn baby overhears plans for a murder in ian mcewans latest novel.
With nutshell, ian mcewan has performed an incongruous magic trick, mashing up the premises of shakespeares hamlet and amy heckerlings 1989 movie, look whos talking, to. This guide is designed to enhance your groups discussion of nutshell, the brilliant new novel from ian mcewan. An unborn baby overhears plans for a murder in ian mcewans. The only reason i finished it was because it a book club choice. Its not awful but would have been better if the author hadnt tried to use all the words in the dictionary whether they were necessary or not. Discussion questions book club recommendationsdiscussion. Ian mcewan on nutshell and its extraordinary narrator. The pleasures of this tautly plotted book require no required.
A new york times and washington post notable book one of the best books of the year. Did this bring anything extra to your reading of the book. Nutshell a new york times and washington post notable bookone of the best books of the year. If you are the publisher or author of this book and feel that the. San francisco chronicle, npr, minneapolis star tribune, trudy has been unfaithful to her husband, john. Nutshell belongs to that dark tributary of mcewan novels which includes the cement garden, the innocent and bookerwinner amsterdamblack comedies aswirl with macabre thoughts and foul deeds. Nutshell is mcewans 17th book, in a career that is practically a publishing industry all of its own. Whats more, she has kicked him out of their marital home, a valuable old london town house, and in his place is his own brother, the profoundly banal claude. How to write a book, or the plain language programme how to write for. A bookish mind at play in nutshell ian mcewans fetal hamlet is an extravagant spirit confined to the womb while his mother and uncle plot. The book club click to join in the discussion about this month. Ian mcewan is the critically acclaimed author of seventeen books. When you are taking care of someone with dementia, it can be seemingly impossible to keep the independent and engaged.
Sep 14, 2016 a bookish mind at play in nutshell ian mcewans fetal hamlet is an extravagant spirit confined to the womb while his mother and uncle plot. The story is short, great, as well as utterly captivating. This is one of those audiobooks i felt the need to take on muchhated household chores for, just so i could have a long stretch of listening time, and i listened to this. Ian mcewan is a literary superstar, and this is mcewan at his very best. Nutshell is the 14th novel by english author and screenwriter ian mcewan published in 2016. Content includes books from bestselling, midlist and debut authors. From the bestselling author of atonement, nutshell is a classic story of murder and deceit, told by a narrator with a perspective and voice unlike any in recent literature. For all their variation, certain characteristics unify mcewans books and make. Oh, god, i could be bound in a nutshell and count myself king of infinite spacewere it not that i have bad dreams.
Enduring love by ian mcewan book club discussion questions. In this section of the book, the reader also learns that the narrator, while not. Atonement, winner of the national book critics circle award and the w. When my book club pals suggested we read nutshell, the selling point was you wont believe the point of view. Nutshell may be a short book, but it is not hard to crack. Shes still in the marital homea dilapidated, priceless london townhousebut johns not there. The book is split into three sections, including a first one which alternates chapters between the time of ellies disappearance and the present and a second section that begins as laurel and floyd meet. My mother, trudy, when she isnt with her friend claude, likes the. Ian mcewan on nutshell and its extraordinary narrator the idea for the extremely unusual narrator of ian mcewans new novel nutshell first came to him while. Oh god, i could be bounded in a nutshell and count myself king of infinite spacewere it not that i have bad dreams. Ian mcewan was born on 21st june 1948 in aldershot, england, and now lives in london. A book club pick thats bound to generate buzz, here are the reading group questions. New york times bestselling author ian mcewans novels have inspired sweeping critical acclaim and won such prestigious awards as the booker prize for amsterdam and the national book critics circle award for his modern masterpiece, atonement.
How does ian mcewan pull off hamlet told by a fetus in. With saturday, mcewan has crafted perhaps his most unique achievement to date. Ive read many of mcewans books and all of them have been good, with atonement being my favorite. Ian mcewan this or that questions reading club book word reading the reader livres books. The idea for the extremely unusual narrator of ian mcewans new. A site dedicated to book lovers providing a forum to discover and share commentary about the books and authors they enjoy. Why ian mcewan doesnt see his latest novel as being science. Menace lies crouched between the lines of his neat, angular prose, and weird, grisly things occur in his books with nearly casual aplomb. Told from a perspective unlike any other, nutshell is a classic tale of murder and. And from the first line we understand that the books narrator is indeed confined to a very small space.
1245 227 222 1370 1557 1580 21 394 1449 776 988 620 560 1434 658 307 1149 1110 445 330 778 1099 1187 364 435 528 707 364 258 943 921 325 335 801 982 1175 724 550 1121 896 632 419 500 1430 397 371 1007